Recently I was looking up the EPA mileage figures for my 1992 Honda Accord 5-Speed and Abby’s 2003 Volkswagen Golf TDI 5-Speed. The fueleconomy.gov site is now listing the new revised MPG figures for new cars. But it looks like they have also adjusted older model years for effective comparison.
My Honda used to be listed as 22 MPG city, 29 MPG highway. My own driving has averaged around 27 MPG with around 25% city, 75% highway. On long trips, it has usually beaten the 29 MPG highway estimate with around 30 or even 31 MPG, despite highways speeds generally 70 and sometimes above. And that average of 27 MPG (since last October, most fill ups included) includes winter driving with shorter trips. And I usually accelerate swiftly frequently with high revs and full throttle (hey, full throttle in this vehicle isn’t that much power!). And, I have a toolbox in my trunk and radio gear, including an antenna which certainly creates drag. What am I doing right?
The EPA has revised the estimate for my Honda to 21 MPG city, 28 MPG highway. I don’t get this. I’m pushing the engine hard, with cold weather, high speeds, full throttle.. and I am rewarded by beating the EPA highway mileage by 2-3 MPG?! I can only imagine what kind of mileage I would be getting if I started driving like a grandma.
Abby’s Golf was originally listed as 44 MPG city, 49 MPG highway. The Golf has easily bested 50 MPG on our customary long trip from New Hampshire to Georgia. Last year the whole trip also included significant long distance commuting which pushed the total to near 4,000 miles. Despite winter tires, heavy loads, high speeds, air conditioning in the south, and cold temps up north. And that car doesn’t get driven gently either.
The EPA revised estimate for the Golf is… 35 MPG city, 44 MPG highway. This is around 6-8 MPG lower than what we typically get on the highway, even under demanding conditions. City is probably around 8-10 MPG lower than what we’ve observed. Is our experience unique? It boggles my mind that anyone could regularly drive the Golf in such a manner that it would get 44 MPG on the highway. I believe you could drive a long highway trip at 85-100 MPH and get 44 MPG.
I suppose I could see how someone could drive the Honda even harder than I do and get worse mileage. But that would certainly not be the way an average driver drives. I would say typically people are more gentle than I am. What is the point of these insanely low estimates released by the EPA?
I am curious about other people’s experiences, so please drop a comment if you keep track of mileage at all. It would be interesting to see how things compare.